Finding the best DHA free self tanner can feel overwhelming, especially if you’re trying to avoid synthetic ingredients, harsh chemicals, or potential skin irritants while still wanting a natural-looking glow. Traditional self-tanners rely on DHA, but many clean beauty lovers are now seeking safer, non-toxic alternatives that deliver results without compromising skin health. In this review, I’m taking a close look at Beauty by Earth Self Tanner—breaking down its ingredients, performance, safety, and whether it truly lives up to the hype as one of the best non toxic self tanners on the market. I also want to discuss what a true DHA free self tanner is and whether or not you may require one for your skin type.
* This post may include affiliate links. This means that products purchased from certain links will generate a small commission (At no extra cost to you). As always, I will only recommend brands that have passed my seal of approval and that I truly love. Thank you for supporting this little holistic space on the internet. *
* Information in this post is not professional medical advice and should not be relied on or used in place of consultation with healthcare professionals. Should you have any medical questions, please consult your primary healthcare provider. **
What Is a DHA Free Self Tanner?
A DHA free self tanner is a sunless tanning product that delivers color without using dihydroxyacetone (DHA), the most common active ingredient found in traditional self-tanners. DHA reacts with amino acids on the surface of the skin to create a temporary bronzing effect, but concerns around irritation, dryness, and inhalation exposure have led many clean beauty consumers to look for alternatives. As demand grows for safer, non-toxic beauty products, DHA free formulas are becoming increasingly popular among those searching for the best DHA free self tanner that aligns with a more holistic lifestyle.
What Is DHA and Why Is It Used in Self Tanners?
DHA is a synthetic sugar derived from glycerin and is approved for external use in sunless tanning products. When applied to the skin, DHA causes a chemical reaction with dead skin cells that darkens the skin’s appearance within a few hours. While DHA is effective at producing fast, noticeable color, it can sometimes leave skin feeling dry, irritated, or uneven—especially for people with sensitive or reactive skin types. This has prompted many to question whether DHA is necessary when looking for the best DHA free self tanner alternatives.
Why Some People Avoid DHA in Skincare Products
Many consumers choose to avoid DHA due to potential concerns around skin sensitivity, oxidative stress, and the lack of long-term research on repeated exposure—particularly when used frequently or inhaled through spray tans. Clean beauty advocates also point out that DHA-based tanners are often paired with synthetic fragrances and preservatives that may further irritate the skin. For these reasons, health-conscious users are increasingly turning to plant-based ingredients and mineral-derived colorants when searching for the best DHA free self tanner that offers a natural glow without compromising skin health.
This begs the question, Is it DHA we need to avoid? Or should we source a naturally derived DHA option without added synthetic ingredients and fragrances. There are different sources of DHA. So first, I want to dig into the differences between them.
Naturally Derived DHA (Sugar Beet) vs. Conventional DHA in Self Tanners
While both Beauty by Earth’s self tanner and traditional sunless tanning products rely on DHA (dihydroxyacetone) to create color, the way that DHA is sourced—and the overall formulation it’s placed in and where the DHA is soured from —can differ in meaningful ways.
Source and Ingredient Philosophy
Beauty by Earth uses DHA derived from sugar beets, a renewable plant source. This type of DHA is produced through a natural fermentation process rather than being synthesized from petroleum-based sources. For clean beauty brands, highlighting plant-derived DHA reflects a broader commitment to ingredient transparency, sustainability, and non-toxic formulation standards.
Conventional self tanners may also use DHA that originated from plant sugars, but the sourcing is often less emphasized. In many mainstream formulas, DHA is treated as a functional ingredient rather than part of a holistic ingredient philosophy, with more focus on speed of color development and shelf stability.
But, many of us don’t want to invest in a product that won’t develop color. So, is a plant based derived DHA the answer? Let’s dig into the details of beet derived DHA.
Formula Design and Skin Feel
One of the biggest differences isn’t the DHA molecule itself, but what surrounds it. Beauty by Earth pairs its sugar beet–derived DHA with moisturizing, plant-based ingredients designed to support the skin barrier and reduce dryness—an issue many people experience with traditional self tanners.
Conventional DHA formulas often rely on synthetic stabilizers, fragrances, or alcohols to improve texture or scent. These additives can contribute to irritation or uneven fading, especially for those with sensitive or reactive skin. This is often why people experience reactions when using a conventional DHA self tanner.
Color Development and Finish
Both sugar beet–derived DHA and conventional DHA interact with the outer layer of the skin to create a temporary tan. However, many users find that self tanners formulated with naturally derived DHA and fewer synthetic additives tend to produce a more natural-looking tone rather than an overly orange or artificial finish.
Because Beauty by Earth’s formula focuses on beet derived DHA sources, the color development and hydration produce better results. The finish is less orange compared to conventional self tanners that use chemically derived sources of DHA. I have personally noticed that using a sugar beet derived DHA created a more natural and bronze look compared to synthetic options I had used in the past. Many Women equate natural products to “lower quality” but in the case of self tanners, a naturally derived source actually produces better results.
Sensitivity and Clean Beauty Appeal
From a safety standpoint, DHA—regardless of source—is intended for external use only. That said, people with sensitive skin often tolerate plant-derived DHA formulas better simply because they contain fewer potential irritants overall.
For those prioritizing clean beauty, sugar beet–derived DHA aligns with a preference for renewable ingredients, minimal processing, and formulas that avoid unnecessary synthetics.
Bottom Line
The difference between Beauty by Earth’s sugar beet–derived DHA and conventional DHA isn’t about effectiveness—it’s about formulation integrity. Beauty by Earth’s approach centers on cleaner sourcing, supportive skin ingredients, and a gentler overall tanning experience, making it a popular choice for anyone seeking a more skin-conscious alternative to traditional self tanners.
| Feature | Beauty by Earth Sugar Beet–Derived DHA | Conventional DHA |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Derived from fermented, plant-based sugar beets | Often lab-produced, with less emphasis on original plant source |
| Ingredient Philosophy | Clean beauty–focused, prioritizing renewable and naturally derived ingredients | Performance-focused, with sourcing transparency varying by brand |
| Overall Formula | Paired with nourishing, plant-based moisturizers and botanical extracts | Frequently combined with synthetic stabilizers, fragrances, or alcohols |
| Skin Feel | More hydrating and comfortable on the skin | Can feel drying, especially on sensitive skin |
| Color Development | Natural-looking bronze tone | Sometimes darker or more orange-toned |
| Fade Quality | Fades more evenly due to hydrating formula | May fade unevenly or cling to dry patches |
| Scent | Typically milder, botanical-based scent | Often has a stronger “self-tanner” smell |
| Sensitive Skin Friendly | Better tolerated by many with sensitive or reactive skin | Higher chance of irritation depending on additives |
| Clean Beauty Appeal | Aligns with non-toxic, holistic, and eco-conscious values | Less aligned with clean beauty unless specifically formulated that way |
Naturally Derived DHA Self Tanner vs True DHA Free Self Tanner: Benefits of Each
Not all “clean” self tanners are the same. Some use naturally derived DHA from plant sources, while others are completely DHA free self tanner, relying on alternative ingredients to create color. Each option has unique attributes depending on your skin type, health priorities, and tanning goals. I am digging into the difference between a true DHA free self tanner vs a naturally derived DHA self tanner so you can choose the right option for you.
Benefits of a Naturally Derived DHA Self Tanner
Naturally derived DHA self tanners use the same tanning molecule as traditional self tanners, but source it from renewable plant materials like sugar beets. This approach offers several advantages for those who still want reliable results while minimizing synthetic ingredients.
One of the biggest benefits is predictable, longer-lasting color. DHA reacts with the outer layer of the skin to create a tan that typically lasts several days and fades gradually. When paired with hydrating, plant-based ingredients—as is common in cleaner formulas—the result is often a more even, bronzed, natural-looking glow with less patchiness.
Naturally derived DHA formulas also tend to avoid harsh additives, making them a better choice for people who want performance without a heavily synthetic ingredient list. For many users, this provides a middle ground between conventional self tanners and fully DHA-free self tanner options.
Are there Benefits of a True DHA Free Self Tanner?
True DHA-free self tanners do not rely on the chemical reaction that DHA creates. Instead, they use botanical colorants, minerals, or cosmetic bronzers to tint the skin. These formulas are often chosen by people who are highly sensitive or avoid DHA entirely for personal or health-related reasons.
A key benefit of DHA-free self tanners is immediate color without chemical development. Because the color sits on the surface of the skin, there’s no waiting period and no risk of the deeper oxidative reaction associated with DHA. This can be appealing for those with very reactive skin or those who want a short-term glow for events or photography.
The issues arise for those who want a self tanner that lasts. True DHA free self tanner options are essentially just a bronze tinted moisturizer for temporary color. DHA-free self tanner options wash off very quickly. They are not the same as a typical DHA self tanner that produces a longer lasting result. That being said, DHA free self tanner options are for people who’ve had issues with DHA-based self tanners in the past. These are often individuals with the most sensitive skin types. As someone with typical sensitive skin, I do not personally react to plant based DHA self tanner options like Beauty by Earth.
Which Option Is Better? Natural DHA vs. DHA Free Self Tanner
After using both options, my personal preference is a naturally derived DHA self tanner. It delivers a longer-lasting, realistic tan. I have sensitive skin and feel comfortable using DHA when it’s sourced thoughtfully and formulated cleanly. A true DHA-free self tanner may be better if you have extreme sensitivity, but I find that they often do not work well at all. I have yet to find a 100% DHA free self tanner that works for me.
Do you Truly Need a DHA free Self Tanner?
After trying a number of different DHA free self tanner options, I have not found one that lasts longer than a day. I personally find that DHA free self tanners also do not deliver a good color. For the little color they do provide, it does not last past the first wash. In my opinion, DHA free self tanners are often a waste of money and do not work they way people want them to.
Additionally, It is quite rare that people truly react to a plant based DHA self tanner option. So, while they are a good thing to offer on the beauty market, they are usually only required and reserved for those with the most sensitive and reactive skin types.
My Favorite Non-Toxic Self Tanner: Beauty by Earth
After testing multiple clean and conventional sunless tanning products over the years, Beauty by Earth stands out as the best non-toxic self tanner I’ve personally used. What sets it apart is its use of naturally derived DHA sourced from sugar beets, combined with a thoughtfully formulated blend of plant-based, skin-nourishing ingredients. Unlike many traditional self tanners that can feel drying or smell overpowering, Beauty by Earth delivers a natural-looking glow that develops evenly and fades gracefully—without irritating my skin or leaving behind that telltale self-tanner scent. For anyone seeking a cleaner, more skin-conscious alternative that still delivers real results, this has become my go-to non-toxic self tanner.
Beauty by Earth Self Tanner Review: My Honest Results & Experience
I’ve used the Beauty by Earth Self Tanner for many years now, and it’s one of the only self tanners I would recommend to others (conventional options included). It offers the same performance as a conventional self tanner, but more bronze toned and made with safer ingredients.
What I noticed first was how easy it is to apply—no sticky residue, no overwhelming smell, and no panic about streaks. The color develops gradually over several hours into a soft, natural bronze that looks like a real tan rather than an obvious self-tanner glow. On my skin, it never turned orange and didn’t cling to dry patches, which has been an issue for me with other self tanners in the past. I also appreciate that it fades evenly, so I’m not left with awkward patches or obvious lines as it wears off. Overall, this has been one of the most reliable, skin-friendly self tanners I’ve used, especially for anyone who wants a cleaner formula without sacrificing results.
Overall, Beauty by Earth is:
- Made with Clean Ingredients
- Provides an Easy Application
- Has No Foul Odor
- Low Streaking Potential
- A Beautiful Bronze Shade (No Orange Hue)
Beauty by Earth Self Tanner Ingredients
Understanding the ingredient list is key when choosing a non-toxic self tanner, which is why taking a closer look at Beauty by Earth self tanner ingredients matters. This formula is designed with clean beauty in mind, using naturally derived, skin-supportive ingredients while avoiding many of the harsh additives found in conventional self tanners. Below is the full list of ingredients found in Beauty by Earth Self Tanner Body Lotion. They are fully transparent about what goes into their formulas. No hidden ingredient lists on their website. While they are not 100% DHA free self tanner, they have one of the cleanest ingredient lists on the market.
Full Ingredients (Self Tanner Body Lotion): Aqua, *Aloe Barbadensis (Aloe Vera) Leaf Juice, *Butyrospermum Parkii (Shea) Butter, Dihydroxyacetone (Sugar Beet Derived), Cetyl Alcohol, Stearyl Alcohol, *Cocos Nucifera (Coconut) Oil, *Glycerin (Vegetable), *Camellia Oleifera (Japanese Green Tea) Leaf Extract, *Punica Granatum (Pomegranate) Extract, *Hamamelis Virginiana (Witch Hazel) Extract, *Vaccinium Macrocarpon (Cranberry) Fruit Extract, *Simmondsia Chinensis (Jojoba) Seed Oil, *Argania Spinosa Kernel (Argan) Oil, Leuconostoc/Radish Root Ferment Filtrate, Cocos Nucifera (Coconut) Pulp Extract, Vanilla Tahitensis (Vanilla) Fruit Extract
*Certified Organic Ingredients
Beauty by Earth Self Tanner Before and After: What I Noticed
Seeing real results is what matters most when choosing a non-toxic self tanner, which is why I wanted to share my Beauty by Earth self tanner before and after experience in detail. From application to color development and fade, the differences were noticeable in ways I don’t usually expect from clean beauty sunless tanners. Below, I’m breaking down exactly how my skin looked and felt before applying Beauty by Earth, and what changed after using it—so you can decide if this self tanner delivers the kind of natural, streak-free glow you’re looking for.
Before Applying Beauty by Earth Self Tanner
Before using Beauty by Earth, my skin tone was fairly even but noticeably pale, especially on my legs and arms. I tend to have dry patches around my knees, ankles, and elbows, which usually makes me hesitant to use self tanner because those areas often grab color and look uneven. I was also cautious about the typical self-tanner smell and the risk of ending up with an orange or streaky result, something I’ve experienced with other products in the past.
After Using Beauty by Earth Self Tanner
After application, the color developed gradually over several hours into a natural, warm bronze that looked like a real sun-kissed tan rather than makeup on the skin. The most noticeable difference was how evenly the color developed—even around dry areas—without clinging or dark patches. There was no harsh self-tanner odor, and my skin actually felt hydrated instead of tight or dry. As the days went on, the tan faded evenly without blotchiness, which made it easy to maintain or reapply without obvious buildup.
Why This Before-and-After Matters
If you’ve struggled with streaky application, uneven fading, or irritation from traditional self tanners, this kind of result is exactly why Beauty by Earth stands out as a non-toxic option that actually performs. It delivers visible color while still being gentle enough for regular use, especially for sensitive or dry skin types.
How to Choose the Best Beauty by Earth Self Tanner for you
There are a handful of different Beauty by Earth Self Tanner options. This feels overwhelming if you aren’t sure which to choose. I wanted to run through the options. This way, you can feel confident in the option you choose to use for yourself.
My two personal favorite Beauty by Earth self tanning products are the self tanner body lotion and the face tanning drops. I have tried all of the formulas and they all work great. There are subtle differences in application, development speed and more. I have attached the graphic below so you can see which products might fit best with your personal preferences.
Beauty by Earth Self Tanner options for Face
As the graphic shows, The Self Tanner Face Serum and the Self Tanner Drops are both forgiving. They will build over time and create a healthy glow. There is less chance of streaking as they don’t apply on their own. Instead, they are mixed with your moisturizer or within their serum. Moisture can help a self tan apply smoothly so using these products on your face can be a great option. I prefer to use my own moisturizer with the tanning drops.
The Face Self Tanner is a great option if you wish to have a tan develop quicker over the face and you don’t mind a thicker product. This may be a good option for an event coming up if you need a tan quickly.
- Self Tanner Drops – Added to your choice of moisturizer, develops over a few days, forgiving and less streaking potential.
- Self Tanner Face Serum – Comes in the form of a serum, develops over a few days, forgiving and less streaking potential.
- Face Self Tanner – Thicker product, tan develops quicker like a typical self tanning product, great for event or when you need a quick self tan.
Beauty by Earth Self Tanner options for Body
The Self Tanner Body Lotion is most hydrating and gives a great glow with only one application. That being said, the Self Tanner Mists and Self Tanner Mousses will dry and develop a little bit quicker. I personally opt for the body lotion because it’s potential for streaking is lower thanks to it’s lotion base. It doesn’t give off a bad smell and it applies beautifully.
- Self Tanner Body Lotion – Most hydrating, develops with one application in a few hours, takes a few minutes to dry on skin after applying.
- Self Tanner Mousse – Develops with one application in a few hours, dries much quicker after application, must ensure your skin is moisturized prior to applying.
- Self Tanner Mist – Develops with one application, dries much quicker after application, thinner consistency than the mousse, must ensure your skin is moisturized prior to applying.
How to Apply Beauty by Earth Self Tanner
Beauty by Earth Self Tanner Discount Code
Beauty by Earth was kind enough to offer a discount code for all THV readers. Use discount code: HOLISTICVANITY at checkout to save on their website HERE.
** Canadians, you can shop Beauty by Earth on Amazon Canada HERE **
Shop Beauty by Earth Self Tanner
Self Tanner Body Lotion
Self Tanner Body Mousse
Self Tanner Body Spray
Face Self Tanner Drops
Face Self Tanner Serum
Face Self Tanner Mist
A few more articles you may enjoy:
- Good Beauty Skincare Review: My Honest Results + Discount Code
- Araza Beauty Discount Code + My Honest Review of the Organic Makeup line
- Manucurist Natural Gel Nail Polish Review + Discount Code
- 10 Incredible Health Benefits of Bovine Colostrum
** PIN the image below to save this post for later **
No Comments